Rule 128 of the Patents Rules, 2003
Directions not otherwise prescribed
Allows the Controller to give directions where the Rules do not prescribe how something is to be done.
Official legal text
The verbatim statutory text of this provision is reproduced from the official source and checked by our legal reviewer before it is published here. Until that check is complete for this page, read the exact wording directly from the official source linked below — it is the only version that governs.
Read this as a plain-language summary. If it and the official text, or a relevant Gazette notification, say different things, the official text and the notification are what count.
What this rule requires, step by step
No set of rules can anticipate every situation. Files arrive with combinations of facts nobody drafting the Rules imagined, and occasionally the Rules say that something must be done without saying how or by when. Rule 128 fills that gap. Where a person is required to do something under the Rules and no particular manner or time is laid down, the Controller may give directions, in writing, telling that person what to do and by when.
Two features of the rule are worth noting. First, the direction is specific to the case in hand. It is not a general power to rewrite the Rules; it is a power to work out how an existing requirement will be met on a particular file. Second, the direction is in writing, which means the person receiving it knows exactly what is expected and can act on it, and a record exists if the matter is later disputed.
The obligation created by a direction is real. A person who receives one and ignores it cannot later say the Rules were silent. In practice, if a direction is not complied with, the Controller can proceed on the material available, which usually means the party who did not respond loses the benefit of what it might have said, and in some situations the application can be treated as not having been put in order.
Rule 128 sits beside Rule 137, which lets the Controller amend documents and condone irregularities in procedure in the interests of fairness, and beside Rule 138, which allows time to be extended. Read together, these are the flexibility rules of the Indian patent system: they let the office deal sensibly with unusual cases instead of refusing to act because no box exists to tick. Where no form is prescribed for a request, Rule 8 provides the general-purpose form.
The right response to a direction under this rule is to comply within the time given, and, if that time is genuinely too short, to say so promptly with reasons rather than to let the date pass in silence.
Why this rule matters
Applicants, patentees, opponents and agents whose files raise a situation the Rules do not spell out.
Whenever the office needs something done and the Rules do not prescribe the manner or the time for doing it.
A power in the Controller to issue written, case-specific directions that the recipient is expected to follow.
The Controller proceeds without the missing material, and the party that stayed silent bears the consequence.
How it works in practice
An unusual proof of assignment
Anvaya Neurotech Pvt Ltd acquired the rights in a pending application from a dissolved partnership firm in Ludhiana. The Rules describe how an assignment is presented for registration, but the company's chain of title ran through a dissolution deed, a family settlement and a partner who had since died, none of which fitted the usual pattern. The Controller issued a written direction identifying exactly which documents the office required, in what order, and the time within which they were to be filed: attested copies of the dissolution deed and the settlement, a death certificate, and a short statement linking each document to the next so the chain could be followed. Anvaya's agent supplied the documents in the sequence directed, with a covering index. The Controller was satisfied and the title was recorded. Had the company simply filed a bundle of papers with no explanation and no response to the direction, the request would have been decided on whatever was on the file.
Simplified illustration only. Actual legal outcomes depend on the facts.
Key points to remember
- Rule 128 applies where the Rules require something but do not say how or when it is to be done.
- The Controller gives directions in writing, tailored to the file.
- The direction fixes what must be done and the time for doing it.
- It is not a power to override the Act or the Rules, only to fill a procedural gap.
- Non-compliance means the Controller decides on the material already on record.
- Rules 137 and 138 provide related flexibility on irregularities and on time.
Common mistakes and misunderstandings
- Treating a written direction as an optional suggestion because it is not one of the numbered statutory deadlines.
- Letting the time in a direction pass and only then asking for more, instead of asking with reasons before it expires.
- Reading Rule 128 as a way to get around a clear requirement of the Act. It applies only where the Rules are silent on manner or time.
Connected provisions
Rules and sections are cited differently and amended differently. On a rule page the connected sections are therefore kept in a separate list, so that a reader quoting this material can attribute each requirement to the correct instrument.
Forms, deadlines and fees
- Where the Controller issues a direction under this rule, the time stated in that written direction governs and should be treated as a hard date.
Open the deadline calculator — and have every date confirmed against the current Rules before you rely on it.
Any official fee connected with this provision is fixed by the First Schedule to the Patents Rules, not by the provision itself. The amount depends on who the applicant is and on whether the filing is made online or on paper, so no figures are reproduced here. How Indian patent fees work.
Related judgments
Case summaries are published only after a qualified reviewer has checked the judgment, the citation and the way the holding is described. Nothing has cleared that review for this provision yet, so nothing is listed here. We would rather show no case note than one that misstates what a court decided. How case notes are prepared.
Questions people ask about Rule 128
What is a direction under Rule 128?
It is a written instruction from the Controller telling a party how, and by when, to do something the Rules require but do not spell out. It arises on a particular file rather than as a general policy, and it usually asks for documents, clarification or a step that the standard forms do not cover. Treat it exactly as you would a formal requisition: note the date, do what it asks, and file the response through the proper channel so it goes on the record.
Can the Controller use this rule to create new requirements?
No. The power is to say how an existing requirement is to be satisfied where the Rules are silent, not to invent obligations that the Act and Rules do not impose. If a direction appears to go beyond that, the sensible course is to respond within the time given while setting out, politely and in writing, why you consider the requirement to fall outside what the Rules require. Silence is the one response that never helps.
What if the time given in a direction is too short?
Ask for more time before the date passes, explaining what you have already done and what remains. Rule 138 allows the Controller to extend time in the cases it covers, up to six months, on a request made within that framework, and Rule 137 allows irregularities in procedure to be dealt with in the interests of fairness. A reasoned request made in advance is far more likely to succeed than an explanation offered after the direction has been ignored.
Received a direction from the Controller you cannot interpret?
MYCrave Consultancy responds to Patent Office directions and assembles the documents an unusual file needs.
You will be speaking with MYCrave Consultancy & Services, the firm that operates this platform. General questions are answered free; matter‑specific work is quoted before anything is done.